August 21, 2007:
As a
result of the 2006 Lebanon war, Israel has decided to shift more money and
effort into upgrading its ground forces. This will mean less money for the air
force, and a delay of several years in getting the new U.S. F-35 stealth
fighter-bomber.
Even before the 2006 war
broke out, the army and air force were having many disagreements on future
threats, and how to deal with them. The basic problem was a different outlook
on planning and risk. The air force sees warfare as a much tidier, and predictable,
affair than does the army. In this respect, the air force and navy are closely
aligned. Both are technical services, who are used to exercising more control
over their forces than do army generals. The army sees warfare as more
unpredictable, and has adapted to that unpredictability. The Israeli army
generals were skeptical of the air forces ability to take down Hizbollah from
the air, and the army guys proved to be right.
During the last decade,
air force generals have come to believe they have a decisive weapon in the form
of smart bombs. These were actually developed and used, with success, at the
end of World War II. But by the 1970s there were laser guided bombs. Very
accurate, but very expensive. By the end of the 20th century the price had come
way down, and the air force believed it was now the dominant service, with an
unbeatable weapon.
This is the attitude that
got the Israelis in trouble last Summer. That all began when, for the first
time, an air force general became Chief of Staff (head of the Israeli armed
forces.) He went along with air force plans to crush Hizbollah from the air.
But here the Israeli air force fell into the same trap that had gotten the U.S.
Air Force into so much trouble over the years. Despite the best efforts of Israeli
intelligence, Hizbollahs efforts to secretly build bunkers in southern Lebanon
were largely successful. The Israelis knew Hizbollah was fortifying the areas
along the Israeli border, which Israel abandoned in 2000 (in an effort to bring
peace to the area). Israel knew something was going on, but depended largely on
aerial reconnaissance (jets, UAVs and some spy satellites) to identify what
Hizbollah was doing. Based on this intelligence, the Israelis worked out plans
for they would deal with Hizbollah, via air and artillery attacks, if war came.
War did come during July, 2006, and it
was quickly discovered that Israeli intel had missed many of the bunker
complexes. These were then discovered, with some difficulty, by Israeli ground
troops.
Not only are the Israeli
ground troops getting new weapons and equipment, but two more armored divisions
are being formed, using Merkava II tanks that were put into storage several
years ago. This indicates some concern that Syria might be tempted to try
another war with Israel, perhaps in cooperation with Hizbollah and Iran. This
sounds like a real long-shot, but when dealing with dictators and Islamic
militants, the insane becomes more probable.